Section 169 (1) of the Small Module Regulations, and Section 167 (1) permit bodies corporate to provide certain types of services, which are not otherwise covered in the legislation. Sub sections 2 and 3 of these Sections also provide the body corporate:-
must have an agreement with each lot owner for whom services are supplied, covering the charges to be made to the lot owner for the installation, maintenance and operating costs associated with the provision of the particular service, but only to the extent necessary for reimbursing the body corporate for supplying the service
ensure the total cost to the body corporate for supplying the service is recovered from the users of the service
There has been some doubt about whether a body corporate can enter into a legally binding agreement with a service provider (including a building manager) to provide such types of service to lot owners without the arrangements in sub clauses 2 and 3 being in place. Obviously if it cannot, the service provider is in a difficult position.
A recent Adjudicator’s decision in the matter of Fairways Golf & Beach Retreat (2017) QBCMCmr 392 backed by a previous decision in the matter of Sylvan Beach Resort (2005) indicates that a body corporate can enter into such legally binding agreement in such circumstances. This is good news for building managers, and other service providers, but bad news for bodies corporate, because the body corporate in such circumstances, has no way to recoup from lot owners, the monies paid to the service contractor in these circumstances, without an agreement with each lot owner benefiting from the service.
In the Fairways case, it was found that the body corporate had entered into an agreement for the supply of pay TV services to lot owners and had put in backbone cabling to allow this to occur. The body corporate tried to recoup the cost of the charges by the supply company for the provision of services, by adding the cost to the administration levy budget. The Adjudicator found this to be illegal in view of the provisions of Section 167 (2) and (3) of the Accommodation Module Regulations.
It is obvious that a building manager who agrees with a body corporate to provide such services, is lining themselves up for future trouble and costs. They would have to have agreements with all lot owners who use such services.
This may be more likely in holiday lets letting appointments, where the POA Letting Authority Form 6 includes such charges to the lot owner, and where fresh Letting Appointments are obtained from the new owner, when a sale of a lot occurs.
The type of services which a body corporate can provide, and pay for, out of the administration fund or the sinking fund, needs modernising to provide a simpler process for supplying and charging for such services, for example, allowing provision for such services in by laws or by special resolution. Perhaps this is something which industry bodies like ARAMA should take up with the government panel currently reviewing the legislation.
Short Punch & Greatorix
Property Bridge 2024
Contributed by Michelle Lim, Senior Lawyer, Mahoneys - 22 December 2020
Contributed by Todd Garsden, Partner, Mahoneys – 30 September 2020
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 24 September 2020
Contributed by William Kenny, Lawyer, Mahoneys – 11 August 2020
Contributed by Frank Higginson, Hynes Legal – 3 August 2020
Contributed by John Punch, Partner, SP&G Lawyers – 22 July 2020
Contributed by John Mahoney, Partner, Mahoneys -19 June 2020
Contributed By Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL - 20 May 2020
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 18 May 2020
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 7 May 2020
Contributed by Mahoneys, 27 April 2020
Contributed by Frank Higginson, Partner and Chris Irons, Strata Adviser HYNES LEGAL – 20 April 2020
Contributed by Trish Riley, Resort News – 9 April 2020
Contributed by John Mahoney, Partner, Mahoneys – 25 March 2020
Contributed by Tony Rossiter, Director, HOLMANS ACCOUNTING & TAXATION – 22 January 2020
Contributed By John Punch, Partner, SP&G Lawyers - 28 November 2019
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 8 November 2019
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 3 October 2019
Contributed by: John Punch of Short Punch & Greatorix Lawyers on 24 September 2019
Contributed by Rhonda Perkins, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 30 August 2019
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 12 August 2019
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 7 August 2019
Contributed by Will Kenny, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 1 August 2019
Contributed by John Mahoney, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 1 August 2019
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 11 June 2019
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 2 May 2019
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 4 April 2019
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 3 March 2019
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 20 May 2019
Contributed by John Mahoney, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 28 February 2019
Contributed by Tony O’Connor, Partner, Short Punch & Greatorix Lawyers - 20 March 2019
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 15 March 2019
Contributed by Will Kenny, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 13 March 2019
Contributed by Mitchell Downes, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 26 February 2019
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 21 November 2018
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 22 October 2018
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 16 October 2018
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 3 October 2018
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 21 August 2018
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 28 May 2018
Darren Brent - Property Bridge - 8 May 2018
Contributed by Short Punch & Greatorix Lawyers – 2 May 2018
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 1 May 2018
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 25 April 2018
Contributed by HOLMANS ACCOUNTING & TAXATION 23 April 2018
Contributed by John Punch, Partner, Short Punch & Greatorix Lawyers - 16 March 2018
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 26 February 2018
Contributed by HYNES LEGAL – 26 Feb 2018
Contributed by Darren Brent, PROPERTY BRIDGE – 12 February 2018
Contributed by Frank Higginson, HYNES LEGAL – 7 February 2018
Contributed by John Mahoney, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 17 January 2018
Contributed by John Mahoney, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 17 January 2018
Contributed by HOLMANS ACCOUNTING & TAXATION 15 December 2017
Contributed by John Mahoney, MAHONEY LAWYERS – 13 November 2017
Contributed By: Short Punch & Greatorix - 20 September 2017
Contributed by MAHONEY LAWYERS – 24 August 2017
Contributed by MAHONEY LAWYERS – 24 August 2017
Contributed by HYNES LEGAL – 8 August 2017
Contributed by HiRUM Software Solutions – 9 August 2017
Contributed by HOLMANS ACCOUNTING & TAXATION -19 July 2017
Contributed by Col Myers, Partner, SMALL MYERS & HUGHES – 22 March 2017
Contributed by SPG Lawyers – 15 August 2016